If you have ever asked “how do buffers work in chemistry?”, start by comparing two beakers. One holds pure water. The other holds a mixture of acetic acid and acetate. Add the same small dose of hydrochloric acid to each, and the buffer’s pH changes much less. The acid has not vanished. In the buffer, most of the added hydrogen ions end up attached to acetate, making more acetic acid instead of remaining in solution as hydronium ions.
Acetic acid, CH3COOH, is a weak acid. In water, it can donate a proton to a water molecule, forming hydronium, H3O+, and acetate, CH3COO−. Acetate is its conjugate base: it can accept a proton and turn back into acetic acid. The reaction goes in both directions.
CH3COOH + H2O ⇌ H3O+ + CH3COO−
You can make this buffer by mixing acetic acid with sodium acetate. The salt supplies acetate ions. Sodium ions are present, but they do not take part in the proton transfers shown here. Acetic acid alone produces some acetate as it dissociates, but adding sodium acetate gives the solution a much larger supply of acetate to react with added acid.
Both members of the pair matter. Acetate accepts protons when you add acid. Acetic acid donates protons when you add base. The pH still moves because each addition changes the relative amounts of the two forms. For another treatment of this equilibrium, see the OpenStax chemistry section on buffers.
Imagine two identical 100 mL samples of buffer. Each contains about 10.0 mmol of acetate and 10.0 mmol of acetic acid. Equal amounts give a starting pH close to the pKa of acetic acid, about 4.76 at room temperature. That means the buffer starts out acidic. A buffer does not have to be neutral to resist pH changes.
Add 1.0 mmol of hydrochloric acid to the first sample. Hydrochloric acid is a strong acid and supplies hydronium in water. Most of that added hydronium reacts with acetate:
CH3COO− + H3O+ → CH3COOH + H2O
For a first estimate, subtract 1.0 mmol from the acetate supply and add 1.0 mmol to the acetic acid supply. That gives 9.0 mmol of acetate and 11.0 mmol of acetic acid. The Henderson-Hasselbalch equation relates the pH to their concentration ratio. Because both forms are in the same final volume, their mole ratio equals their concentration ratio.
pH ≈ pKa + log10(acetate concentration / acetic acid concentration)
Using 9.0 / 11.0 gives an estimated pH of 4.67, a drop of about 0.09 pH unit. For comparison, if the same dose were added to pure water and the final volume were about 100 mL, the resulting pH would be about 2. In pure water there is no comparable stock of acetate to take up the added protons.
Now add 1.0 mmol of sodium hydroxide to the second sample, which still has its original amounts of both forms. Sodium hydroxide supplies hydroxide ions. Acetic acid transfers a proton to hydroxide, turning it into water and leaving behind acetate:
CH3COOH + OH− → CH3COO− + H2O
This time the acetate supply rises to about 11.0 mmol, and the acetic acid supply falls to about 9.0 mmol. Using 11.0 / 9.0 in the same equation gives a pH of about 4.85. The pH rises, but the solution stays acidic. The two calculated changes are equal and opposite because the two ratios are reciprocals, not because every buffer responds equally to acid and base.
A useful way to check your work is to predict the direction before touching a calculator. Added acid should lower the acetate to acetic acid ratio and lower the pH. Added base should raise both. If your calculation says otherwise, check which form you put on top. The IChC learning resources can support practice with the equilibrium and mole calculations behind this example.
Now start over with the original buffer and add 9.0 mmol of hydrochloric acid instead of 1.0 mmol. The same mole bookkeeping leaves about 1.0 mmol of acetate and 19.0 mmol of acetic acid. The estimated pH drops to about 3.48. The buffer has not lost every acetate ion, but it is already much less able to handle another addition of acid. Losing 1.0 mmol from a supply of 10.0 mmol is a small fraction of the supply. Losing the same amount from a supply of 1.0 mmol is not.
If the total dose exceeds the initial acetate supply by enough, excess strong acid largely determines the pH. At the point where the mole calculation gives zero acetate, do not try to take the logarithm of zero. The solution still contains acetic acid, which dissociates and produces some acetate. The pH there is a weak acid equilibrium problem rather than a calculation using the original buffer ratio. In the other direction, enough sodium hydroxide can consume nearly all the acetic acid, leaving the solution poorly equipped to handle more base.
The starting pH tells you about the ratio, not how many millimoles are available. For a practice problem, compare the original 100 mL sample with a 100 mL sample containing only 1.0 mmol of each form. Both start near pH 4.76, but a 1.0 mmol acid dose nearly uses up the acetate in the more dilute sample. When working through IChC training and practice problems, try writing the amounts before and after the addition before deciding which pH calculation fits.
Does a buffer keep pH exactly constant?
No. Adding acid or base changes the ratio of the buffer components, so the pH changes too. The buffer makes that change smaller.
Can two buffers have the same pH but different capacities?
Yes. Two acetate buffers can have the same ratio and nearly the same pH, but the one with more acetic acid and acetate per liter can handle a larger dose for the same volume.
Why does acetate react when I add acid?
Acetate is a base, so it accepts a proton from hydronium. This makes acetic acid and water.
About the International Chemistry Competition: an online chemistry competition for high school students from around the world. Qualification Round 2027: submissions are open until Sunday, 3 January 2027. How the rounds work